Skip to main content
Proto's Pizza Front Entrance

Staying True to Our Roots

Il Gusto Pizza was founded by the Proto family, who brought their lifelong love of pizza-making from New York to open this Manhattan pizzeria. We still use the original dough recipe passed down from generations, making each pie with care and the highest quality ingredients.

Our pizzas are never rushed - we let the dough proof properly and cook each pie to perfection in our stone deck ovens. We source ingredients like tomato sauce and mozzarella from the best local NYC purveyors to craft an authentic slice you’ll love.

Serving Quality Pizzas Since 2012

We are a welcoming neighborhood spot in the East Village, a place to gather with friends and family over amazing food. Our cozy shop has a casual atmosphere where you can enjoy a cold beer and a hot slice at the counter or relax in our dining area.

We pride ourselves on being a beloved Manhattan pizzeria, serving up piping hot, fresh pizzas, heroes, pasta, salads, and more, made just how you like it.

Whether you’re joining us for lunch, dinner, or takeout, our friendly staff provides excellent service that keeps our NYC customers returning.

Pepperoni Pizza

Reviews from our Customers

I wasn't even going to get pizza, but I love small locally owned pizza shops, so when I saw this one, I had to give it a try.  Glad I did.  This is first class. - Google Reviews

Ignatz Mouse
Google Reviews

After a long day we decided to give it a go at Proto's Pizza - we had three different slices and enjoyed them very much! - Facebook

Pizza Love
Facebook

We just randomly walked into this place. And the pizza was amazing, I might visit here again if I got a chance. - Google Reviews

Kelin
Google Reviews