Skip to main content

Il Gusto Pizza: A New York Tradition

For over 10 years, Il Gusto Pizza has been dishing out mouthwatering, New York-style pizza fresh from our ovens to your neighborhood. Our classic recipes and homemade ingredients pack bold, authentic Italian flavor into every bite.

Stop by today to taste a piece of New York tradition born right here in your community.

Sliced Pizza with Toppings
Slice Icon

Fresh, Quality Ingredients

We source the freshest local ingredients to craft authentic Italian flavors in every bite.

Scooter Icon

Fast Delivery & Takeout

We pride ourselves on getting hot, fresh food to your door or table in 30 mins or less.

Award Icon

Squeaky Clean Kitchen

Our pristine, hygienic kitchen earns top health inspection marks.

Plate Icon

Your Menu, Your Way

Customize to your taste with lots of options and special requests.

Order Online

Get our food delivered to your door!

Pizza Online Delivery

Something for Every Craving

Browse our menu organized into categories featuring Italian favorites like pizza, pasta, sandwiches, salads, and more. We use family recipes and quality ingredients to craft each dish.
Appetizers

Appetizers

Start off with appetizers like our Chicken Tenders, Dough Balls Formaggi, and Mozzarella Fritti.

Salads

Salads

Enjoy fresh, healthy salads like our Mozzarella Tomato and classic Caesar.

Spaghetti Pasta

Pasta

From baked pasta to noodle dishes, find all your Italian pasta favorites here.

Entrée

Entrées

Hearty main courses like chicken parmesan, eggplant parm, and more.

Heros

Heros

Loaded hot and cold sandwiches piled high on fresh Italian bread.

Pizza Slice

Pizza

Pizza slices, 10-inch personal, 14-inch thin crust, and 18-inch pies with traditional, specialty and custom topping options.

What Our Customers Are Saying

“Very fresh and tasty. I forget the name but I recommend get this which is chicken and cheese with marinara sauce.” - Google Reviews
Ayda Pour
Google Reviews
"We just randomly walked into this place. And the pizza was amazing, I might visit here again if I got a chance." - Google Reviews
Kelin
Google Reviews
"I wasn't even going to get pizza, but I love small locally owned pizza shops, so when I saw this one, I had to give it a try.  Glad I did.  This is first class." - Google Reviews
Ignatz Mouse
Google Reviews
"Friendly staff and great pizza!! Buffalo chicken slice is the best I’ve had, and the plain is delicious!" - Google Reviews
Bella Tokyo
Google Reviews
"After a long day we decided to give it a go at Proto's Pizza - we had three different slices and enjoyed them very much!" - Facebook
Rubin Smajli
Facebook Reviews
"We were welcomed with smile, humor and a passion for awesome pizza! We had about four different types and all were delicious. The crust was thin, crispy and baked just right." - Facebook
Rachel Bernhardt
Facebook Reviews
"Friendly, quick service and excellent pizza. I usually get the white pizza. TVs with sports and Mr. Bean." - Yelp
Anna G
Yelp Reviews
"Came in for a quick bite and was amazed on the quality of pizza. My family had 3 different slices and all were great" - TripAdvisor
Very Good Pizza
TripAdvisor Reviews
Contact Us

View Google Maps

50 2nd Avenue, New York, NY 10003

Monday 11am-10pm 
Tuesday 11am-10pm
Wednesday 11am-10pm
Thursday 11am-12am
Friday 11am-2am
Saturday 11am-2am
Sunday 11am-10pm


Call us: (646) 767-0056

Subscribe for Updates

Get delicious recipes, special announcements, event info, and more delivered to your inbox.

We promise not to flood it - just occasional updates to give you an inside look at what's happening at Il Gusto Pizza. From new menu items to special deals and more, you'll be the first to know when you subscribe.

Join our community of pizza lovers today!